Historic McKaig House in Cherokee Park Enters Market for $3.5 Million

SARASOTA, FLA. (March 24, 2025) — A rare and distinguished offering located at 1744 South Drive is now available in Sarasota’s prestigious Cherokee Park. The historic McKaig House, a masterfully preserved 1936 Colonial Revival estate, is now available for $3,500,000. Poised on over half an acre of exquisitely landscaped grounds, this remarkable residence seamlessly blends timeless elegance with modern refinement. The property is marketed exclusively by Tom Hedge and Monica Barth of The Hedge Team of Premier Sotheby’s International Realty’s Downtown Sarasota office. The listing details may be viewed here. Originally crafted by esteemed builders Logan and Currin, the McKaig House is an enduring testament to superior craftsmanship and architectural excellence. Every detail of its meticulous preservation honors its 1930s heritage, with original wood floors, high ceilings, intricate wood moldings, and plaster walls. Recent enhancements by renowned local builder Richard Perrone have introduced contemporary luxuries, including an exquisitely redesigned primary suite and a stunning solarium-style kitchen and great room, framed by soaring eight-foot glass windows that invite abundant natural light. A grand entry foyer welcomes guests with an elegant solid oak staircase, setting the tone for the home’s refined interior. The formal dining room is graced with antique brass sconces and French doors opening onto a screened porch. The living room, featuring the original wood-burning fireplace with a gas hookup, evokes a timeless charm and warmth. The gourmet kitchen is an unparalleled culinary sanctuary, designed for both functionality and style. Adjacent to the kitchen, a spacious mudroom and pantry provide additional storage and convenience. The main-level primary suite serves as a private retreat, thoughtfully designed with two custom walk-in closets and an opulent en-suite bath featuring J. Tribble vanities, mystery white quartzite countertops, a walk-in shower, and a freestanding tub. The upper level boasts three additional bedrooms, including an en-suite guest room and a shared guest bath. The property’s exterior is equally captivating, with a detached two-car garage and an original casita-style bedroom and bath, offering an ideal guest suite or home office. The lush, fenced-in backyard, shaded by majestic century-old trees, presents an expansive setting for outdoor leisure and is perfectly suited for the addition of a luxurious pool. Cherokee Park is one of Sarasota’s most coveted residential enclaves, offering an unparalleled lifestyle with convenient access to Southside Village, Sarasota Memorial Hospital, Selby Gardens, the Sarasota Bayfront, downtown Sarasota, and the world-renowned Siesta Key Beach. Residents enjoy the charm of this historic neighborhood, exploring its picturesque streets by bike, golf cart, or on foot. “The McKaig House is not merely a residence; it is a legacy — a rare embodiment of Sarasota’s architectural heritage and refined living,” said Tom Hedge and Monica Barth. “Opportunities to acquire an estate of this stature, with such a distinguished provenance and an exceptional setting, are exceedingly rare.”   About Premier Sotheby’s International Realty Headquartered in Naples, Florida, Premier Sotheby’s International Realty has over 1,400 sales professionals in 40 locations throughout Florida and North Carolina. Premier Sotheby’s International Realty also benefits from an association with the storied Sotheby's auction house, established in 1744. The brokerage was founded by The Lutgert Companies, a prominent member of Southwest Florida’s business community since 1964, and is proudly associated with Peerage Realty Partners. For more information, visit premiersothebysrealty.com.